TM Pro Plumbing crew standing in front of their work vehicles
All articles

Swapping Your Toilet in a Bathroom Reno

by TM Pro Plumbing
RENOVATIONS

By Thomas Masters · 6 min read

Swapping Your Toilet in a Bathroom Reno: What Actually Has to Line Up

Buying a new toilet for a bathroom renovation is easy. Getting one that fits the plumbing you already have is the bit that catches people out.

Most shopping results talk about style and finish. What they rarely cover is the plumbing angle: the trap type, the set-out, and where the water comes into the cistern. Those three things decide whether the suite you like will go in cleanly, or whether you are ordering something that will not suit the pipes behind the wall and under the floor.

This guide is that plumbing angle. For a plain-English look at the main toilet styles themselves (close coupled, back to wall, wall hung, rimless and more), see our types of toilets guide. It has more detail on the different types of toilets. Here we stay on what has to line up when you swap one during a reno.

If you are planning the whole bathroom timeline as well, our guide to how long a bathroom renovation really takes covers the trade stages from the plumbing side. For bathroom renovation plumbing on Sydney builds and renos, see our Bathroom Renovations work.

Older close-coupled toilet with an exposed cistern beside a narrow basin cabinet in a tiled bathroom
Before: older toilet with exposed cistern
New back-to-wall toilet with a concealed cistern, next to a narrow basin cabinet in a tiled bathroom
After: upgraded to a back-to-wall toilet

See our guide to types of toilets.

The styles in brief

The styles in brief (the full guide is elsewhere)

In most family bathrooms you will see a close coupled suite, a back to wall pan, or, when the job is opened up for a renovation, an in-wall cistern or wall hung pan. Rimless bowls are common on newer suites.

We will not re-cover how each style looks and feels here. That is already in the types of toilets post. What matters for a swap is whether the new pan and cistern match the waste and the water connection you already have.

Set-out

Set-out: why it decides what will fit

Set-out is the relationship between the wall (or finished face) and where the toilet waste sits. An S-trap pan is very precise on set-out, so you have to know what the existing toilet set-out is before you order.

If you are unsure, the safest move is to call us or your plumber before you buy. We can give you options for which toilet will suit what is already there.

S-trap versus P-trap

S-trap versus P-trap: what happens when the new toilet does not match

A P-trap pan comes with an S&P adapter so it suits both. An S-trap won't, and is very precise on set-out, so check your existing set-out and call before ordering.

In plain terms: if you pick the wrong trap style for what is in the floor, you do not "make it work" with a different looking suite. You either choose a pan that suits what is there, or you are into changing the waste, and that is a different job to a simple changeover.

Water inlet position

The most common surprise: where the water comes in

The other thing that catches people when they buy a toilet without checking first is where the water comes in: the water inlet position. That can be checked beforehand too.

Cisterns are fed from the bottom or from the rear (or top/rear), and the supply in your bathroom is already in one place. If the new cistern expects the inlet somewhere else, you find out on install day. Checking the inlet position before you shop avoids that surprise. Our types of toilets guide also covers bottom versus rear entry in more detail.

Behind the wall

What has to change behind the wall

How much changes behind the wall depends on the style you are moving to and what is already built in.

A like-for-like swap on the same trap and set-out is the simplest path. Moving to a different style, especially one that hides the cistern in the wall or hangs the pan off a frame, usually means the wall cavity and the rough-in have to be right before tiling. We check that on site rather than guessing from photos.

Concrete cutting

When a swap means cutting concrete

It depends if it is slab on ground or a suspended slab.

Concrete cutting is only really practical if it is a full bathroom renovation, as we are not allowed to cut the waterproofing. So when changing a toilet, you are very limited, unless you are doing a whole bathroom renovation. And then some would require concrete cutting to make the set-out off the wall.

Before you go shopping

Before you go shopping: a short practical checklist

You do not need a full redesign quote to avoid a bad buy. Before you order a suite, check:

  1. 1

    Trap type

    Whether what you have suits an S-trap or a P-trap path, remembering a P-trap pan comes with an S&P adapter so it suits both, and an S-trap won't.

  2. 2

    Set-out

    Especially if you are looking at an S-trap pan, check the existing set-out distance. If you are unsure, call TM Pro before you order.

  3. 3

    Where the water comes in

    Bottom or rear/top entry, so the cistern matches the supply you already have.

  4. 4

    Style versus structure

    If you want wall hung or an in-wall cistern, confirm the wall and rough-in can take it before you buy. We will check that on site.

If any of those are unclear, call before you shop. It is much cheaper than returning a suite that will not fit.

Choose first, check later

Mistakes we see when people choose first and check later

These are the slip-ups that turn a simple toilet swap into a return or a bigger job.

  • Ordering on looks alone, then discovering the trap or set-out does not match.
  • Assuming every "universal" looking suite will suit every bathroom.
  • Skipping the water inlet check and finding the cistern feed is in the wrong place on the day.
  • Planning a style change (for example into the wall) without confirming what has to change behind the tiles.

None of those are hard to avoid. They just need a quick check, or a phone call, before the card comes out.

Need a toilet that will actually fit?

If you are mid-renovation in Sydney and you want a second set of eyes on trap, set-out and inlet before you buy, call TM Pro Plumbing on 0487 869 984. We will talk you through which toilet options suit what is already in your bathroom, with clear pricing and no hidden extras.

For bathroom renovation plumbing more broadly, see our Bathroom Renovations work with builders, and for renovation timing from the plumbing side read how long a bathroom renovation really takes.

Need help with your plumbing?

Request a booking with our licensed Sydney plumbing team, with up-front pricing and no hidden extras.